Are the positioning tags used in personnel‑location systems interchangeable? Can tags from different manufacturers be mixed and matched?
Category:
Author:
Aviation and Optical-Electronic Technology
Source:
www.hangfeigd.com
Release Date:
2026-07-02
Quick answer: In the vast majority of cases, personnel‑location cards from different manufacturers are not interoperable. Proprietary communication protocols, inconsistent data formats, and differing encryption methods constitute the three primary barriers. 2026 year 4 Monthly national release GB/T 47520-2026 Information Technology Real-time positioning system Ultra-Wideband Positioning Air Interface Protocol , unified UWB The air interface protocol for positioning devices—devices compliant with this standard will achieve cross‑vendor interoperability—and the standard will be… 2026 year 11 month 1 day It has been officially implemented. Until then, the safest approach remains to opt for a complete system from the same manufacturer.
Release Date: 2026 year 7 month 2 day
The positioning card of this article Refers to the personal positioning tags worn by personnel in a personnel positioning system—such as employee badges, chest cards, wristbands, and similar forms—and does not include access control cards, payment cards, or other cards used for purposes other than personnel tracking.
Q1 : Can the positioning tags of a personnel positioning system really be used interchangeably?
Brief answer: In most cases, they are not universally compatible, but under specific conditions, interoperability can be achieved.
To understand this issue, we must first clarify why the positioning card… “ Not universal ”。
The personnel positioning system is a complete closed-loop. —— The positioning card (tag) transmits a signal, the base station receives it, and the backend software calculates the location. Between different manufacturers, everything—from communication protocols and data formats to encryption methods—can vary significantly. It’s much like Apple’s… AirTag It can only be used within the Apple ecosystem; Samsung’s… SmartTag Primarily compatible with Samsung devices. —— There exists a relationship between the positioning card, the base station, and the backend system. “ Pairing ” Relationships—just grab any other bank’s card, and the system simply… “ Don't know ” It.
At present, the vast majority of personnel‑location systems on the market rely on proprietary communication protocols, and achieving interoperability between base stations and positioning tags from different manufacturers requires substantial additional investment to implement protocol adaptation. According to industry reports, 2025-2030 In [year], the size of China’s indoor positioning market will grow from... 360 Increased from hundreds of millions of yuan to 780 hundreds of millions of yuan; in such a vast market, “ Can positioning cards be used universally? ” It directly affects the enterprise’s future equipment procurement costs and the flexibility of system scalability.
Q2 : Do positioning cards of different technical types vary in their versatility?
Yes. Different positioning technologies vary in their level of standardization and differ significantly in their versatility.
Currently, mainstream positioning technologies include UWB (Ultra-Wideband), Bluetooth, ZigBee 、 RFID and so on; their performance in terms of generalizability differs significantly:
Type of technology | Level of standardization | Versatility | Key Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
UWB (Ultra-Wideband) | National standards already exist. | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (Potentially universal) | GB/T 47520-2026 Published, 2026 year 11 month 1 After the implementation of the regulation, devices that comply with national standards will be able to interconnect and interoperate. |
Bluetooth | Open at the infrastructure layer, proprietary at the application layer. | ⭐⭐ (Limited General) | Bluetooth itself is an open standard, but manufacturers differ significantly in their application-layer protocols. |
ZigBee | Theoretical standard, actual private | ⭐ (Basically not universal) | Many manufacturers have implemented proprietary modifications to standard protocols, resulting in poor actual compatibility. |
RFID (Active) | Lack of unified standards | ⭐ (Basically not universal) | Communication protocols vary significantly among manufacturers, resulting in limited interoperability. |
UWB aspect : In the past, manufacturers used proprietary protocols that were incompatible with one another, resulting in “ Equipment silos ” . But 2026 year 4 In [month], the State Administration for Market Regulation and the National Standardization Management Committee issued… GB/T 47520-2026 Standard; this standard has unified UWB The following key requirements for positioning devices:
- Unified Air Interface Protocol : Standardize the physical layer and MAC Layered working method
- Unified Security Mechanism : Ensuring the security of communication between devices
- Scope of Application : Design, development, manufacturing, testing, and deployment of base stations and tags within the system
This means, 2026 year 11 month 1 After the day As long as both the positioning card and the base station comply with the relevant national standard, interconnection and interoperability across vendors can, in theory, be achieved.
In terms of Bluetooth Bluetooth technology itself adheres to open standards, but manufacturers often define their own data formats and broadcast content at the application layer. Its interoperability depends on whether they follow the same broadcast format and protocol stack.
ZigBee aspect : In theory, as long as everyone follows the standard ZigBee The protocol allows communication, but the problem is that… —— Many manufacturers do not fully adhere to standard protocols but instead implement proprietary modifications.
RFID aspect : Passive RFID There are relatively mature international standards (such as ISO 14443 、 ISO 15693 ), the card reader level offers good compatibility. However, in personnel positioning systems, it is used… Active RFID , Communication protocols vary significantly among manufacturers, and their interoperability remains limited.
Q3 Why can’t positioning cards from different manufacturers be used interchangeably?
There are three core reasons:
Reason 1: Inconsistent communication protocols
The positioning card and the base station communicate via a specific “ Air Interface Protocol ” Conduct communication. In the past, each manufacturer had its own proprietary protocol. A The signal emitted by the manufacturer’s card, B The manufacturer’s base station is fundamentally… “ I don’t understand. ”— It’s like one person speaks Chinese, while the other only understands English.
Reason 2: Incompatible data format
Even if communication is possible, the data formats output by different manufacturers may still be entirely different. —— The definitions, order, and encoding schemes of fields such as location information, status information, and battery‑level information all differ. As a result, the backend system is unable to parse them correctly.
Reason 3: Different encryption methods
To ensure the security of positioning data, manufacturers employ different encryption algorithms. Even when the protocols are identical, mismatched encryption methods will prevent normal communication. In compliance with national standards… UWB Taking devices as an example, the standard has standardized the security encryption mechanism, fundamentally resolving this issue.
Q4 : What does “universal compatibility” for positioning cards NOT mean?
Clarify three “ Not equal to ” , to avoid misunderstandings:
❌ Not all brands can integrate seamlessly.
Compliance with national standards merely ensures interoperability. “ Technical Foundation ” , it does not mean that devices from any two brands can be used simply by plugging them in. Compatibility testing and configuration are still required between devices.
❌ Not equal to plug-and-play; no configuration required.
Even when the protocols are identical, devices from different manufacturers may still differ in network parameters, operating modes, and other aspects, necessitating appropriate configuration and debugging during deployment.
❌ It does not mean that older devices automatically comply with the new standard.
Older equipment purchased prior to the implementation of the national standard typically does not gain automatic support for the new standard through software updates. When mixing new and legacy devices, careful validation remains essential.
Q5 So, is there currently a way to achieve compatibility among positioning cards from different manufacturers?
Yes. There are two main pathways:
Path One: Follow the national standard (with UWB For example)
GB/T 47520-2026 The implementation of, for UWB The positioning device interoperability standard across manufacturers provides a unified technical specification. Selecting positioning tags and base stations that comply with this standard represents a reliable pathway toward universal compatibility in the future. Issued by the Standardization Administration of China, this standard carries authoritative weight and serves as a mandatory guiding framework.
Option 2: Choose an integrated vendor that has developed its entire stack in-house.
Some manufacturers with strong technical capabilities adopt “ Fully developed in-house ” Strategy —— From chip-level firmware to the backend platform, everything is developed in-house; all devices… “ Speak the same language ” . Although such systems are incompatible with other brands, devices within their own ecosystem can collaborate seamlessly, fundamentally eliminating compatibility issues. In 2026 In the current industry landscape, in-house R&D capabilities have become the primary criterion for evaluating and selecting personnel‑tracking solution providers.
Q6 As the purchaser, how should I make my selection?
Here are three practical tips for you:
Tip 1: Whenever possible, choose a complete system from the same manufacturer.
Unless you have clear technical validation, it is not recommended to mix positioning tags and base stations from different manufacturers. The safest approach is to choose products from the same manufacturer. Positioning card + Base station + Backend software Integrated solution. This ensures full compatibility in communication protocols, data formats, and encryption methods, resulting in a stable and reliable system.
Recommendation 2: Pay attention to national standards and choose compliant products.
For UWB Positioning system, We strongly recommend prioritizing devices that are already compatible. GB/T 47520-2026 Standard product These products not only hold the potential for future cross‑vendor interoperability, but also position their manufacturers at the forefront of technological innovation, making investments more secure.
Recommendation 3: Clearly inquire with the manufacturer about compatibility.
Before placing an order, be sure to confirm the following points with the manufacturer:
- Can your positioning cards be used with base stations from other brands?
- Whether to support GB/T 47520-2026 National standard?
- If equipment needs to be expanded or replaced in the future, how will compatibility be ensured?
- Can legacy devices support the new standard through a software upgrade?
Q7 : How will the versatility of future positioning cards evolve?
The trend is clear: from “ Acting independently ” toward “ Open and Integrated ”。
Technical level , UWB Leveraging centimeter-level positioning accuracy, the technology has already established a foothold in scenarios such as mining. 52% market share. 2025 Global personnel for the year UWB The market size of positioning tags is approximately 11.25 hundred million yuan, with an estimated arrival by 2032 The year is drawing to a close. 24.92 Billions of yuan. Driven by such a massive market, standardization is an inevitable trend.
Policy Level ,2025 In [year], China released a new version of the technical specifications for underground personnel positioning systems in coal mines, raising the required positioning accuracy from… 3 Rice raised to 0.5 Meter. GB/T 47520-2026 Its promulgation and implementation further provide, at the national level, UWB Interoperability among positioning devices has been unblocked.
However, it should be noted that , it takes time to implement the standards. —— On the one hand, manufacturers must carry out technological upgrades; on the other, it is impossible to replace all existing equipment overnight. During the transition period, the mixed use of equipment from different manufacturers still requires careful validation.
Summary
Question | Answer |
|---|---|
Are positioning cards universally compatible? | At present, the vast majority are not universally compatible. |
Can products from different manufacturers be mixed? | Mixing is generally not recommended. |
What is the main reason? | The protocol is proprietary, the data formats differ, and the encryption methods vary. |
UWB Will positioning cards be universally compatible in the future? | GB/T 47520-2026 After implementation, products that meet the standards will be interoperable. |
When will the national standard be implemented? | 2026 year 11 month 1 day |
How should you choose when making a purchase? | Prioritize a complete system from the same manufacturer and ensure compliance with national standards. |
Reference materials :
- GB/T 47520-2026 Information Technology Real-time positioning system “Ultra-Wideband Positioning Air Interface Protocol,” National Standards Information Public Service Platform, https://std.samr.gov.cn/[reference:28]
- “Global Mining Personnel Positioning Industry Survey and Development Research Report ( 2026 Year)》
- 《 2026 Global and Chinese personnel for the year UWB Research Report on Market Share and Rankings of Leading Companies in the Positioning Tag Industry
This document is prepared based on industry‑standard technical principles and national standards. For specific product compatibility, please refer to the manufacturer’s technical documentation. For more information on selecting personnel positioning systems, please stay tuned.