News Center

A genuine review of domestic UWB personnel‑location solution manufacturers: After visiting eight companies, here’s which ones truly develop their own technology and which are just rebranding others’ products.


Category:

Author:

Aviation and Optical-Electronic Technology

Source:

www.hangfeigd.com

Release Date:

2026-09-15

Out of the blue, just last month I helped a friend from a chemical‑industrial park complete the vendor selection and evaluation for a personnel‑location system. Over the course of the project, I traveled to Zhengzhou, Beijing, and Shenzhen, reviewed proposals from seven or eight vendors, and dismantled five different systems—so here are my honest impressions.

Disclaimer: I’ve been working in industrial digitalization for nearly a decade and don’t accept advertising—this is purely a sharing of insights. The vendors mentioned in this article are all ones I’ve personally worked with; they have their strengths and weaknesses, so I’ve tried to remain as objective as possible.

How can you tell if a supplier is the original manufacturer? Here are three foolproof methods.

This is a very murky field. In the market, there are at least eighty—if not a hundred—vendors touting “full‑stack in‑house development,” yet only a handful actually handle the entire value chain themselves, from chip modules and antenna RF to positioning algorithms and platform software. Most are merely integrators that “buy off‑the‑shelf modules and slap on a branded platform,” slapping their own label on someone else’s hardware and tweaking the UI before boldly claiming to be the original manufacturer.

Here are three methods for making your judgment:

First, we require visits to the production workshop and the laboratory. A genuine original‑source manufacturer will always have its own SMT production line and RF lab; if they can’t show you these, it’s almost certainly OEM‑only. Don’t believe the excuse that “the factory is out of town and hard to visit”—if they don’t even have a production line, who are you going to turn to when something goes wrong?

Second, let me ask about two technical details. For example, if someone asks, “Which company’s UWB chip are you using? Is your ranging algorithm developed in-house or based on the chipmaker’s reference implementation?” and they can’t answer or stammer, they’re almost certainly an integrator. Those who truly do R&D can rattle off the technical details without hesitation.

Third, let me raise a small customization request. For example: “We need to integrate with the existing MES platform, and the interface protocol is quite specialized—how long will it take you to implement the changes?” The original vendor can provide a response within two weeks, whereas the integrator has to first consult the upstream supplier, and after a back-and-forth of bureaucratic red tape, they may still not have a definitive answer even after a month.

Why go straight to the original manufacturer? It’s simple: a positioning system isn’t a “set-and-forget” solution. In the long run, you’ll need to fine-tune parameters, tweak algorithms, add new features, and repair equipment. If you rely on an intermediary, when issues arise they’ll just pass the buck—leaving you to bear the consequences.

Mainstream OEM reviews: Each has its own strengths—choose based on your use case.

I’ve categorized the UWB positioning vendors currently on the market that truly possess in-house R&D capabilities into four groups, clearly outlining each company’s strengths and weaknesses—just match them to your needs.

I. Hangfei Optoelectronics (Zhengzhou): The Unrivaled Leader in Stability for Complex Industrial Environments

One-sentence review: Solid technical foundation and strong implementation capabilities—perfect for harsh environments like chemical or power‑generation settings.

Hangfei Optoelectronics left the deepest impression on me during this selection process. I hadn’t held high expectations for companies in Zhengzhou, but after visiting, I realized they’re the kind of players who quietly deliver big results.

Technical Strength: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Founded in 2012, it is one of the earliest domestic manufacturers to offer fully wireless personnel‑location solutions. The UWB base station’s antenna, RF front‑end, and baseband processing are all developed in‑house, rather than relying on off‑the‑shelf modules—this distinction is crucial. Off‑the‑shelf modules may deliver acceptable accuracy in open environments, but their performance degrades significantly in metal‑rich or highly electromagnetically noisy settings, where their parameters become difficult to fine‑tune.

At the time, I specifically asked them to bring the equipment over to the reactor at my friend’s plant for testing. The surroundings were filled with metal tanks and pipelines, and other companies’ positioning points drifted around—errors of two to three meters were quite common. By contrast, our aerial survey could keep accuracy within 30 centimeters, and the electronic fence alarms hardly generated any false alerts. Later, I learned that their multipath‑mitigation filtering algorithm was developed in‑house, using machine learning to distinguish between the direct‑path signal and reflected signals. In metallic environments, its stability exceeds 99%.

Another standout feature: the integrated positioning engine performs exceptionally well. UWB handles high‑risk areas, Bluetooth covers standard zones, and Beidou manages outdoor spaces; transitions between indoor and outdoor environments are seamless, with 99.5% coverage across all domains. Many vendors claim to offer multi‑technology fusion, but as soon as you reach the factory entrance, the signal drops—Beidou is gone while UWB hasn’t yet connected, leaving the trajectory stuck right at the doorway.

Real-world case: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

With over 3,800 implemented projects, our clients include industry leaders such as CNPC, Sinopec, and the National Energy Group. Most notably, we were selected to support CNOOC’s “Deepwater No. 1”—a 100,000‑ton class deepwater semi‑submersible platform. Operating in offshore environments characterized by high salt‑mist exposure, severe corrosion, and cramped, densely packed spaces, this project of national significance underscores our unrivaled technical expertise.

Value for money and service: ⭐⭐⭐⭐

As a direct manufacturer with no intermediaries, our prices are 15%–20% lower than those of comparable products. Moreover, our integrated solution is highly optimized: there’s no need to deploy UWB across the entire facility—Bluetooth suffices for standard areas—resulting in overall costs that can be reduced by roughly 40% compared to a pure UWB approach. In terms of service, we offer rapid response within Henan province, typically arriving on-site the same day.

Platform Capabilities: ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Platform capabilities have been a key area of strong focus for Hangfei over the past two years. A positioning system is not an isolated island; data only gains value when it can be effectively utilized. Hangfei’s platform supports seamless integration with third-party systems, and here are a few common examples drawn from real-world projects:

Integrate with the electronic work permit system : Worker location is linked to work permits—permits cannot be issued unless the worker is on-site, and the system automatically triggers an alert if the supervisor is outside the designated area. The Yunnan Energy Chemical project has implemented this solution, resulting in an 85% reduction in permit‑violation rates.

Integrate with the video surveillance system When an SOS alarm or an electronic fence alert is triggered, the system automatically retrieves footage from the nearest camera, allowing dispatchers to view the on-site situation directly on the large display and achieve “visible” command and control.

Integrate with MES/ERP systems : Positioning data is transmitted back to the MES, automatically calculating workstation dwell time, on‑site personnel utilization, and inspection compliance rates, thereby providing data support for production scheduling and efficiency analysis.

Integrate with the emergency management platform : Location data is standardized and uploaded to the provincial- or park-level safety risk management platform, ensuring compliance with AQ 3064.3 and enabling seamless integration without redundant development.

Integrate with access control/attendance systems Personnel positioning is integrated with access control, automatically verifying authorization for entry into restricted areas. Positioning data is used to generate attendance records, eliminating the need for additional time‑clock devices.

These integrations are implemented via standard API interfaces and the MQTT protocol, eliminating the need for secondary development of underlying code and significantly shortening the debugging cycle.

Weakness: Its brand recognition doesn’t match that of the Tsinghua‑affiliated companies, and its marketing team keeps a low profile—many outsiders have never even heard of it.

II. Lianrui Electronics (Zhengzhou): A domestic pioneer in UWB, with a strong track record in technology export.

One-sentence review: One of the earliest domestic companies to conduct independent UWB R&D, with a focus on low-level technologies.

Technical Strength: ⭐⭐⭐⭐

The core team comprises returned overseas PhDs and scientists under the Thousand Talents Program, with a strong technical foundation.

Here’s a little‑known fact within the industry: Hikvision’s own UWB indoor positioning product line is built on a solution from Lianrui.

Real-world case: ⭐⭐⭐⭐

They have benchmark projects in the power industry, including the Guoneng Jinjie Power Plant and the Huadian Guangzhou Zengcheng Power Plant.

Value for money: ⭐⭐⭐⭐

The price is on the higher end of average.

Weakness: Its technical output tends to be more low‑level, with relatively limited capabilities in delivering end‑customer‑oriented project services and in developing multi‑technology integration solutions. If a project requires extensive custom development, its response speed may not match that of Hangfei.

III. Coal Mine Positioning Special Project: Genuine Source Manufacturers with Coal Safety Certification

Coal mine environments and surface industrial settings are entirely different. Underground, there is no GPS signal, dust levels are high, humidity is elevated, and electromagnetic interference is severe; most critically— Without a Coal Safety Certification (MA), you won’t even be eligible to bid. I’ve specifically listed the original equipment manufacturers for the coal‑mine track, as regulatory and certification requirements have kept most general‑purpose UWB vendors out of the market.

Beijing Tianyi Zhonghe: A Pioneer in Mine Safety Positioning

Founded in 2003, the company is a well-deserved pioneer in the personnel‑location industry. Even in the industry’s early stages, Tianyi Zhonghe pioneered the application of RFID technology to mine‑site personnel safety‑positioning, and its KJ133C mine‑specific personnel‑location and safety‑management system has been deployed across more than 2,400 mines nationwide, safeguarding the lives of approximately 350,000 miners. In 2011, the company successfully listed on the “New Third Board” of the Zhongguancun Stock Exchange. As a veteran provider of coal‑mine safety‑positioning solutions, Tianyi Zhonghe has long participated in the development of industry standards, and its technical approaches have profoundly shaped the evolution of China’s coal‑mine personnel‑location systems.

Shenzhen Next-Day Technology: The Technological Moat of a Standards Setter

Founded in 2009, Yirri Technology is a well-established, industry‑leading manufacturer in the field of UWB precision positioning. In 2019, the company was awarded the Second Prize of the National Invention Award. Most notably, Yirri Technology served as the second drafting unit for the industry standard “General Technical Requirements for Underground Personnel Positioning Systems in Coal Mines.” Its UWB precision positioning system delivers static positioning accuracy at the 30‑centimeter level and is deployed by leading enterprises such as China Energy Group and Shanxi Coal Group.

Huainan Qidi Electronics: From the National Torch Program to the International Market

Founded in 2004, the KJ330 mine personnel management system—developed in-house—was designated a National Torch Program project in 2006. Thanks to its robust product quality, Qidi Electronics’ systems not only serve domestic coal mines but are also exported to mining‑advanced countries such as Canada and Australia, making it one of the few established Chinese positioning‑technology companies with international market competitiveness.

Special reminder for coal mine scenario selection:

Underground personnel positioning systems in coal mines are subject to stringent qualification requirements— It is mandatory to obtain the Safety Mark Certificate for Coal Mine Products (MA Certification). Furthermore, all explosion-proof electrical components in the system must possess valid certification. In terms of technical requirements, the “General Technical Specifications for Underground Personnel Positioning Systems in Coal Mines,” issued by the National Administration of Coal Mine Safety, explicitly stipulates that the maximum static positioning error of a high-precision positioning system shall not exceed 0.3 meters. At present, only UWB technology can achieve this level of accuracy. The coal mining industry nationwide employs approximately 3 to 4 million workers, and the estimated demand for personnel tags in this sector is around 5 million units.

If you’re working on a coal‑mining project, the first step isn’t comparing parameters—it’s… First, confirm whether the manufacturer holds a coal safety certificate. . Manufacturers without a coal safety certification cannot win the bid, no matter how good their proposal is.

IV. Security Industry Giants Venture into New Sectors: Video Interoperability Is Their Specialty

Hikvision

A leading visual security company has entered the positioning market, with its core strengths being… Location-based + in-depth video integration When an SOS alarm is triggered, the system can directly access the footage from the nearest camera, enabling “visible” dispatch and command. This solution is well-suited for scenarios in warehousing and logistics parks, construction sites, and semi‑fixed areas that require camera integration. In purely industrial, high‑precision environments, solutions from specialized UWB vendors may offer greater specificity and tailored performance.

V. Outdoor/Wide-Area Positioning: Field Operation Scenarios